Is military strategy, as taught in professional military education, too closely tied to the endswaysmeans paradigm. In other words, strategy is about ensuring that the appropriate means were available to achieve the ends or goals with the ways. Modern strategic thinking is characterised by the ends, ways, means relationship and the concept of the way as shortest possible direct connection between ends and means. After describing the security environment in which military forces will operate, the nms report must specify the ends, ways, and means of the strategy. This chapter decodes the alphabet soup of us weapons sales and military aid programs, providing background on them and on other arms industry buzz words. All too often, it seems that in many western professional military education institutions strategy and strategy formation have been largely reduced to a simple formula of ends, ways, and means.
Military strategy is often divided into four components. Together, strategy and tactics bridge the gap between ends and means figure 1. Strategic uncertainty, the third offset, and us grand strategy by ionut c. A national military strategy is usually influenced by civil political and economic decisions. Through the tet offensive in 1968, some have argued that the united states did not have a firm strategy in vietnam. Analyzing the russian way of war modern war institute. The central statement that strategy is a pervasive and enduring aspect of human history describes the theory, practice, and predictions surrounding the study of strategy posited by colin gray in his 2015 book, the future of strategy. Parameters winter 20162017 open pdf 3 mb parameters published by the u. Huntingtons book became the standard in the field, and it remains the starting point for. And its primary objectives are control and paralysis. It discusses the essential elements of any strategy. Theory of strategy makes the radical argument that the familiar structure of strategys general theory political ends, strategic ways, military means and assumptions holds as sound for security at all times and in all places, of human necessity. Military challenges from rivals like russia and china are clearly a priority for naval posture and force design given the navy and marine corps we have today and are planning for the future.
Definitions of strategy saass comps prep wiki fandom. Strategy formulation is recognized as both an art and science, and the u. Nov 03, 2014 all too often, it seems that in many western professional military education institutions strategy and strategy formation have been largely reduced to a simple formula of ends, ways, and means. Means refers to the military resources manpower, materiel, money, forces, logistics and so forth required to accomplish the mission. The process is politicized, there is no governmentwide unity of effort, and there is no buyin or commitment across the governments interagency. It takes place in wartime and peacetime and may involve using force, directly or indirectly, as a threat. In the field of military theory, the operational level of war also called the operational art, as derived from russian.
This joint doctrine note jdn describes national strategy, defense strategy, and military strategy. Oct 31, 2007 ends, ways, means and cog analysis will greatly enhance military planning. Some basic concepts and approaches in the study of international. Clausewitzs concept of strategy balancing purpose, aims.
May 25, 2007 the primary nature of any strategy, whether it is military campaign, business, marketing or games, is the relationship between ends, ways, and means. Its time to end the tyranny of ends, ways, and means. With our general concept of strategy as a guidestrategy equals ends plus ways plus means we can develop an approach to military strategy. The nms report describes the relationship of those objectives to the strategic environment, regional, and international threats. In business, as in the military, strategy bridges the gap between policy and tactics. Taylors published books and speeches also do not show that he. Additionally, i expose the principles of war as a myth, instead. Army war college strategy model of ends, ways, and means is expounded on and advocated as a methodology for articulating strategies. Of these three items, the one that seems to be the most problematic is determining the goal, or end. It is the link between military means and political ends, the scheme for how to make one produce the other.
Ends are defined as the strategic outcomes or endstates desired. Officer 2020 strategy nco 2020 provides vision and guidance on ends, ways, and means for developing ncos that exercise mission command while planning, preparing, executing, and assessing unified land operations to meet the challenges of the 21 st century and preserve the combat readiness of our force. The national security strategy is not a strategy foreign. The wonderful world of classification march 20, 2020. The combination of decreasing defense spending and rapid increases in the cost of new weapons suggests that a strategy for conflict with china should assume limited. Ends, ways and means in vietnam the leavenworth way of war. Military strategy is the direction and use of force for the purposes of policy as decided by politics. He also drew on the wellknown british military theorist, b. Belligerent rhetoric in north koreas propaganda by mason richey.
Dec 19, 2017 as soon as it was released on december 18, u. Foreign policy and the rand corporation teamed up to bring together many of the key players who launched, fought. The document, an attempt to turn trumps america first instincts into a foreign policy doctrine, had failed to align ambitious ends with ways and means. Foreign policy and the rand corporation teamed up to bring together many of. Mar 15, 20 on march 19, it will have been 10 years since the united states invaded iraq. Ends, ways, and means this is the final installment of a series on leader development. Given our current, hardedged calculus of ends, ways, means, and risk, we need more clarity than that.
The crisis of american military primacy and the search for strategic solvency by hal brands and eric edelman. However, where has this strategic formula of ends, ways, means come from. Its time to end the tyranny of ends, ways, and means modern. Generally, strategy is about developing a goal, setting out a plan, and then allocating needed resources. Jan 17, 2018 as one article in a russian military journal puts it, the indirect action strategy against western adversaries will draw on, above all, a great variety of forms and methods of nonmilitary techniques and nonmilitary measures, including information warfare to neutralise adversary actions without resorting to weapons. It is convenient and concise, short enough to fit cleanly onto a powerpoint slide and clear enough to be expressed as an actual mathematical equation. Such neglect is a structural issue, inherent to the u. Ends are the objectives or desired outcomes of a given strategy.
Oct 18, 2018 the definition of strategy offered by gray in this work then is this. What is my desired endstate for the officers or ncos i. May 07, 2018 military strategy revisited a critique of the lykke formulation, the author of the article explores current understanding of ends, ways, means, and risk to create a new formulation for developing a strategy toward a political end state. Lykke was not the first or only theorist to put forth an ends, ways, means way of looking at strategy. Sadly, the ends, ways, and means never seem to be in balance. Wylie invented the intellectual framework and terminology with which to understand strategy as a means of control. As such, it is in the public domain, and under the provisions of title 17, united states code, section 105, it may not be. Texts about military strategy take us back into the mists of time but what it is, and what the nature of war is, remains hotly debated. With our general concept of strategy as a guidestrategy equals ends plus ways plus meanswe can develop an approach to military strategy.
The best books on military strategy five books expert. A military history of the united states from 1607 to 2012, 3rd edition by allan r. Here, ends is the objective, such as global conquest, maximising market share, neutralising a crisis, etc. This book is a useful start point for any student of strategy, strategic history, and for those who seek to understand its foundation, formulation, and fallibility. He synthesized the four existing specific theories of strategy into one general theory that is as valid today as when it was first created. Ends, ways, means, risk strategy is much like a three legged stool of ends, ways, means balanced on a plane of varying degree of risk. The concept of ends, ways, and means provides one logical framework. In essence, this becomes an examination of courses of action designed to achieve the military objective. Having in the foregoing chapter ascertained the complicated and variable nature of war, we shall now occupy ourselves in examining into the influence which this nature has upon the end and means in war if we ask first of all for the aim upon which the whole war is to be directed, in order that it may be the right means for the attainment of the. One subject area embroiled in this debate is military strategy, where there are demonstrable gaps in knowledge and perspective between the military and academic communities. Military strategy revisited a critique of the lykke formulation. Pointers for researching each of these programs are included, as well. Encirclement both a strategy and tactic designed to isolate and surround enemy forces.
Similar to developing a coherent national strategy, there are sequential steps we should take in crafting our unit leader development programs. Strategy is evervarying in its character, but not in its nature, which is unchanging. These courses of action are termed military strategic concepts. In the case of a nms, the equation is rewritten to reflect the national level of military strategy.
For a strategy to be coherent it must logically connect ends, ways, and means. Balancing what is described in the following chapters as ends, ways, an d meansremains at the core of the army war colleges approach to national security and military strategy and strategy formulation. Military strategy is the practice of reducing an adversarys physical capacity and willingness to fight, and continuing to do so until ones aim is achieved. Jul 24, 2017 lykke was not the first or only theorist to put forth an ends, ways, means way of looking at strategy. It focuses on the development of nationallevel military strategy and how the military instrument of power is used, in combination with the other instruments of national power, in pursuit of policy objectives.
List of military strategies and concepts wikipedia. Unlike traditional means, knowledge is relatively cheap and easy to balance with ends and ways. On march 19, it will have been 10 years since the united states invaded iraq. Pdf military strategy revisited a critique of the lykke formulation. In sum, it is difficult to apply the ends, ways, and means paradigm of strategy to information age security. Understanding military strategy and the four levels. Strategic and operational concepts are the ways of the strategy and describe how the armed forces conduct military operations to accomplish the specified military objectives. Apr 17, 2014 modern strategic thinking is characterised by the ends, ways, means relationship and the concept of the way as shortest possible direct connection between ends and means.
Strategy equals ends objectives toward which one strives plus ways courses of action plus means instruments by which some end can be achieved. If strategy is nothing else than the direct way of linking the political purpose with the means, understood as combat, this understandings results in battle. Army war college professor celestino perez demonstrates, national decisions to employ the military are frequently and hotly debated. It is an analysis model used by the military and civilian national security community at the strategic level. Ways are defined as the methods, tactics, and procedures, practices, and strategies to achieve the ends. Lykkes seminal formulation of military strategy, defining military. National military strategy united states wikipedia. Jul 24, 2018 theory of strategy makes the radical argument that the familiar structure of strategy s general theory political ends, strategic ways, military means and assumptions holds as sound for security at all times and in all places, of human necessity. Ends are defined as the strategic outcomes or end states desired. President donald trumps first national security strategy nss met with an expected wave of criticism. Us national military objectives are the ends, describing what the armed forces are expected to accomplish. Us army war college guide to strategy commonwealth institute. Sep 24, 20 similar to developing a coherent national strategy, there are sequential steps we should take in crafting our unit leader development programs. Each of the following chapters highlights a major concept used in our strategy formulatio n model.
Minitheories of military strategy, consisting of the five basic military strategies of extermination, exhaustion, annihilation, intimidation and subversion, are woven together into a coherent military strategy theoretical framework. Since the aim of strategy is to link ends, ways, and means, the aim of strategic leadership is to determine the ends, choose the best ways, and apply the most effective means. Thucydides history is conventionally divided into eight books. Mar 21, 2018 this caught my eye so i did a bit of searching. For example, the ends, ways, and means construct is used at the national. Antulio echevarria ii of the us army war college talks us through key books, both old and new, on military strategy. Art lykke and the development of the ends, ways, means model nsi. After four decades of relative stability in national security strategy, american behavior has been erratic in search of a new and sustainable role on the world stage.
Having in the foregoing chapter ascertained the complicated and variable nature of war, we shall now occupy ourselves in examining into the influence which this nature has upon the end and means in war. Grand strategy can be understood simply as the use of power to secure the state. Unlike conventional ways, cyberwar defies the military principle of mass. Ways are concerned with the various methods of applying military force. The purpose of this report is to examine russian military strategy and how it was shaped by the 2008 russiageorgia war in order to understand moscows military objectives in the current conflict in ukraine and how it executes cyber, psychological, and so called hybrid warfare against western s tates. Us military practice from the revolution to afghanistan by antulio j. The nms report describes the relationship of those objectives. Ends, ways and means clausewitz was clear about the connection between ends, ways, and means describing them as a paradoxical trinity. Liddell hart also defined strategy as the art of distributing and applying military means to fulfill the ends of policy.
385 382 658 657 1101 1441 1077 216 231 1523 1359 1136 1076 139 1398 92 1142 786 1501 1317 146 1160 1238 113 678 567 85 180 462 277 1356 436 1034 16 1482 274 1088 574 1082 332 789 1145 88 863 832 1124 724 508